Should You Claim Social Security at 62 During a Market Downturn?

Should You Claim Social Security at 62 During a Market Downturn?

How Sequence of Returns Risk Can Change the Answer

Should you claim Social Security at 62 if the stock market falls just as you retire?

Possibly.

Claiming Social Security early permanently reduces your monthly benefit. However, waiting for a larger benefit may require you to withdraw substantially more money from your retirement accounts during the first several years of retirement.

If those withdrawals occur during a significant market decline, the damage to your portfolio may be difficult to overcome.

This is why the decision about when to claim Social Security should not be based solely on your monthly benefit or a simple breakeven calculation. Your claiming decision should be evaluated alongside your investments, spending needs, taxes, life expectancy, and the condition of the market when you retire.

How Much Is Social Security Reduced at 62?

Social Security retirement benefits can generally begin as early as age 62.

For someone whose full retirement age is 67, claiming at 62 generally reduces the worker’s retirement benefit by approximately 30 percent. A benefit of $3,000 per month at age 67 would therefore be approximately $2,100 per month at age 62.

That reduction generally continues for the remainder of the retiree’s life.

According to the Social Security Administration, claiming early provides benefits for a longer period, but at a reduced monthly amount. Waiting until full retirement age provides a larger monthly benefit for fewer years.

There is no universally correct claiming age. The Social Security Administration also states that the decision should be based on the individual’s personal circumstances.

The Social Security Decision Most People Miss

Many Social Security comparisons focus almost entirely on the monthly benefit.

For example:

  • Claim at 62 and receive approximately $2,100 per month
  • Wait until 67 and receive $3,000 per month
  • Delay until 70 and potentially receive an even larger benefit

Based on those numbers alone, waiting can appear to be the obvious choice.

But where will your income come from while you wait?

If you retire at 62 and delay Social Security until 67, your retirement portfolio may need to fund five full years of living expenses. That can be manageable when the market performs well.

It can be much more dangerous when retirement begins during a significant market decline.

What Is Sequence of Returns Risk?

Sequence of returns risk is the danger created when poor investment returns occur early in retirement while you are also withdrawing money from your portfolio.

The order in which investment returns occur matters because retirees are no longer simply buying and holding investments. They are regularly selling investments to pay for living expenses.

If the market falls and you do not need to withdraw money, you may have time to wait for a recovery.

If the market falls and you must sell investments to generate retirement income, you may be forced to sell more shares at depressed prices. Those shares are no longer available to participate in the eventual recovery.

Two retirees could earn the same average investment return over 20 years and still experience very different outcomes. The retiree who suffers losses during the first few years of withdrawals may run out of money much sooner.

Mike’s Social Security Decision

Consider a hypothetical retiree named Mike.

Mike retires at age 62 with:

  • $800,000 in his 401(k)
  • $60,000 in annual spending needs
  • A projected Social Security benefit of $3,000 per month at age 67
  • An estimated benefit of $2,100 per month if he claims at 62

We will compare two choices.

Option One: Mike Claims Social Security at 62

Mike receives approximately $25,200 per year from Social Security.

To meet his $60,000 annual income need, he withdraws the remaining $34,800 from his 401(k).

Option Two: Mike Waits Until 67

Mike receives no Social Security between ages 62 and 66.

His entire $60,000 annual income need must come from his 401(k). At age 67, he begins receiving $36,000 per year from Social Security and reduces his annual portfolio withdrawal to $24,000.

What Happens If the Market Falls 20 Percent?

Now assume the market falls 20 percent during Mike’s first year of retirement.

After that initial decline, the following five annual returns average 6 percent. Both strategies experience the exact same sequence of market returns.

For simplicity, this example:

  • Uses level annual spending of $60,000
  • Does not include taxes
  • Does not include Social Security cost of living adjustments
  • Does not include investment fees
  • Assumes annual withdrawals occur before the investment return
  • Uses rounded figures
Mike’s ageMarket returnClaim at 62: year end 401(k)Wait until 67: year end 401(k)
Starting balance$800,000$800,000
62Negative 20%$612,160$592,000
63Positive 14%$658,190$606,480
64Negative 4%$598,455$524,621
65Positive 11%$625,657$515,729
66Positive 3%$608,583$469,401
67Positive 6%$608,209$472,125

By the end of age 67, Mike has approximately $608,000 remaining if he claimed Social Security at 62.

If he waited until 67, he has approximately $472,000 remaining.

That is a difference of approximately $136,000.

Mike receives a larger Social Security benefit by waiting, but he enters age 68 with considerably less money invested.

Why Did Claiming Early Protect More of the Portfolio?

When Mike claimed Social Security at 62, he only needed to withdraw $34,800 annually from his 401(k).

When he waited, he needed to withdraw $60,000 annually for five years.

That additional $25,200 annual withdrawal occurred at the worst possible time: immediately after a major market decline.

The early Social Security income reduced the number of investments Mike needed to sell. That left more money invested for the subsequent recovery.

This does not prove that claiming at 62 is always the better choice. It demonstrates that Social Security cannot be evaluated separately from the portfolio being used to fund the delay.

Why Waiting Until 67 Could Still Be Better

There are many situations in which waiting for a larger Social Security benefit may be appropriate.

Waiting may be more attractive when:

  • You have enough cash or guaranteed income to avoid selling investments
  • Your portfolio is large relative to your spending needs
  • You expect to live well beyond the average life expectancy
  • You want to maximize your guaranteed lifetime income
  • You are the higher earning spouse and want to protect a potential survivor benefit
  • You are still working and do not need Social Security
  • Your health and family history support planning for a long retirement

The Social Security Administration notes that someone with a full retirement age of 67 can generally receive a larger benefit by waiting beyond full retirement age. Delayed retirement credits can increase benefits until age 70.

The value of that larger benefit can become increasingly important later in life, particularly if investment assets decline or one spouse dies.

When Claiming at 62 May Be Worth Considering

Claiming early may deserve consideration when:

  • You need income immediately
  • Claiming reduces withdrawals from a vulnerable portfolio
  • You retire during or immediately before a significant market decline
  • You have health concerns or a shorter life expectancy
  • You are the lower earning spouse in a coordinated household strategy
  • You have limited retirement savings relative to your income needs
  • Delaying would require you to sell investments at depressed prices

The key phrase is “worth considering.”

A market decline by itself does not automatically mean you should claim Social Security. The decision should be tested using your actual income needs, account values, tax situation, benefit estimates, and family circumstances.

Look Beyond the Traditional Breakeven Calculation

A traditional Social Security breakeven analysis compares the cumulative benefits received at different claiming ages.

That calculation can be helpful, but it does not tell the entire story.

If you delay Social Security, you may need to replace those missing benefit payments with additional portfolio withdrawals. Those withdrawals create an opportunity cost because the money is no longer invested.

A more complete analysis should compare:

  • Total Social Security received
  • Remaining investment assets
  • Required portfolio withdrawals
  • Taxes created by those withdrawals
  • Future required minimum distributions
  • Survivor benefits
  • Longevity
  • The effect of different market sequences

The goal is not necessarily to maximize Social Security. It is to create the most durable overall retirement income strategy.

Social Security Should Be Part of Your Retirement Income Plan

Your Social Security claiming decision affects much more than the size of your monthly check.

It can influence:

  • How much you withdraw from your 401(k) or IRA
  • How your investments recover after a market decline
  • Your taxable income
  • Your Roth conversion opportunities
  • Your future required minimum distributions
  • Your Medicare premiums
  • Your surviving spouse’s income
  • How long your retirement savings may last

At Pearl Wealth Group, we believe Social Security should be evaluated as one part of a complete retirement plan.

Our Your Financial EKG™ process is designed to evaluate your income, expenses, investments, taxes, Social Security, healthcare costs, and potential retirement risks together.

The right question is not simply, “How can I get the largest Social Security check?”

The better question is, “Which Social Security strategy gives my complete retirement plan the greatest opportunity to succeed?”

Frequently Asked Questions

Is claiming Social Security at 62 always a mistake?

No. Claiming at 62 results in a smaller monthly benefit, but it also provides income sooner. It may reduce the amount you need to withdraw from your investments during the early years of retirement. The right choice depends on your health, spending, investments, taxes, marital status, and other income sources.

How much is Social Security reduced if I claim at 62?

For someone whose full retirement age is 67, claiming retirement benefits at 62 generally results in approximately a 30 percent reduction. A projected benefit of $3,000 per month at 67 would be approximately $2,100 per month at 62. Your actual amount should be verified through your personal Social Security record.

Should I claim Social Security if the stock market falls?

Not automatically. A market decline is one factor to consider. Claiming may help reduce portfolio withdrawals, but you should also evaluate your cash reserves, life expectancy, taxes, other income, survivor benefits, and long term retirement needs before making the decision.

What is sequence of returns risk in retirement?

Sequence of returns risk is the possibility that poor investment returns early in retirement, combined with ongoing withdrawals, will permanently weaken your portfolio. Selling investments after a decline leaves fewer assets available to participate in a future market recovery.

Is waiting until age 67 always better?

No. Waiting provides a larger monthly benefit, but it may require larger portfolio withdrawals before benefits begin. Waiting can be beneficial for retirees with sufficient assets, other income, longer life expectancies, or a need to maximize survivor income. It is not automatically the best choice for everyone.

Should the higher earning spouse delay Social Security?

In many cases, delaying the higher earner’s benefit can strengthen the potential survivor benefit available to the remaining spouse. However, the best strategy depends on both spouses’ ages, earnings records, health, life expectancy, and income needs.

Can I claim Social Security at 62 if I am still working?

Yes, but benefits may be temporarily withheld if your earnings exceed the Social Security earnings limit before full retirement age. Once you reach full retirement age, Social Security adjusts your benefit to account for months in which benefits were withheld. Review the current rules before claiming while employed.

Does Social Security receive cost of living adjustments if I claim early?

Yes. Someone who claims early can still receive future Social Security cost of living adjustments. However, those adjustments are applied to the reduced benefit amount, so the initial claiming decision continues to affect future monthly payments.

What factors should I consider before choosing a Social Security claiming age?

Consider your life expectancy, health, marital status, survivor benefits, employment income, taxes, retirement expenses, investment balance, withdrawal needs, market risk, and other guaranteed income. The decision should be tested within a complete retirement income plan rather than made using one rule of thumb.

Final Thoughts

Delaying Social Security can create valuable guaranteed income later in retirement. But delaying is not free if you must heavily draw down your investments while you wait.

When retirement begins during a market decline, claiming Social Security early may help reduce portfolio withdrawals and protect more of your investments for a future recovery.

That does not make age 62 the right answer for everyone. It means the timing of Social Security should be coordinated with the timing of portfolio withdrawals.

Before deciding, compare the complete effect of each option on your income, investments, taxes, survivor benefits, and long term retirement security.

To learn more about Social Security retirement planning or to have your retirement strategy evaluated, contact Pearl Wealth Group or explore our Your Financial EKG™ retirement planning process.

Sources: Social Security Administration: Starting Retirement Benefits Early and Important Things to Consider When Planning for Retirement.

This information is provided for educational purposes only and should not be construed as personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Social Security rules and individual circumstances can change. Consult the Social Security Administration and qualified financial professionals before making a claiming decision. Investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. No investment strategy can guarantee a profit or protect against loss during declining markets.

Scroll to Top
Call Now Button