Should You Avoid IRMAA? Roth Conversions and Medicare Premiums

Should You Avoid IRMAA When Planning Roth Conversions?

Avoiding Medicare IRMAA can reduce your premiums for a particular year, but it should not automatically control your entire retirement tax strategy.

A Roth conversion, capital gain, retirement account withdrawal, or other income event may push you into a higher Medicare premium bracket. In some situations, limiting that income makes sense. In others, accepting a temporary Medicare surcharge could help reduce future taxable retirement balances, required distributions, or taxes for a surviving spouse.

The right question is not simply, “How do I avoid IRMAA?” A better question is, “Which combination of taxes and Medicare premiums produces a reasonable long term result for my retirement plan?”

What Is Medicare IRMAA?

IRMAA stands for Income Related Monthly Adjustment Amount. It is an additional amount that some higher income Medicare beneficiaries pay for Part B and Part D.

For 2026, the standard Medicare Part B premium is $202.90 per month. IRMAA begins when modified adjusted gross income exceeds $109,000 for an individual or $218,000 for a married couple filing jointly. CMS publishes the complete 2026 premiums and income ranges.

Medicare uses a modified adjusted gross income calculation that generally includes adjusted gross income from the federal tax return plus tax exempt interest. Social Security normally uses income information from two years earlier. For example, 2026 premiums are generally based on 2024 tax information. Review Social Security’s IRMAA MAGI rules.

That delay is important. A retirement tax decision made today may affect Medicare premiums approximately two years later.

2026 IRMAA Brackets

The following table shows the 2026 thresholds for most individual and joint filers:

2024 MAGI for individual filer2024 MAGI for joint filers2026 Part B premium per personPart D IRMAA per person
$109,000 or less$218,000 or less$202.90$0
More than $109,000 to $137,000More than $218,000 to $274,000$284.10$14.50
More than $137,000 to $171,000More than $274,000 to $342,000$405.80$37.50
More than $171,000 to $205,000More than $342,000 to $410,000$527.50$60.40
More than $205,000 but below $500,000More than $410,000 but below $750,000$649.20$83.30
$500,000 or more$750,000 or more$689.90$91.00

The Part D amount is added to the premium charged by the beneficiary’s prescription drug plan. Different rules apply to certain married individuals filing separately. Social Security provides the complete 2026 tables.

IRMAA operates more like a set of steps than a gradual tax bracket. Moving slightly above a threshold can cause the full increase associated with the next tier.

How Roth Conversions Affect IRMAA

A Roth conversion moves assets from a pretax retirement account into a Roth account. The previously untaxed portion of the conversion is generally included in gross income for the year of the conversion.

Because IRMAA uses adjusted gross income as part of its calculation, a taxable Roth conversion can increase the income Social Security later uses to determine Medicare premiums.

Suppose a married couple completes a conversion that moves their income from $217,000 to $220,000. If both spouses are enrolled in Medicare Part B and Part D, that small move above the 2026 joint threshold could produce:

  • An additional $81.20 monthly Part B charge for each spouse
  • An additional $14.50 monthly Part D charge for each spouse
  • A combined annual increase of approximately $2,296.80

This is a hypothetical illustration based on the 2026 premium table. It assumes both spouses are enrolled for the entire year and does not include their regular Part D plan premiums.

The example demonstrates why retirement tax planning needs a margin for unexpected interest, dividends, capital gains, mutual fund distributions, or other income.

Why Avoiding IRMAA Is Not Always the Best Answer

A Medicare surcharge is a real cost, but it is only one part of a multiyear retirement plan.

Someone with $1 million to $2.5 million saved may hold a substantial percentage of those assets in traditional 401(k)s and IRAs. Those accounts may eventually produce taxable withdrawals and required minimum distributions.

Avoiding every Roth conversion to keep current income below an IRMAA threshold could leave more money in pretax accounts. Depending on future tax rates, investment growth, withdrawals, and family circumstances, that may create larger taxable income later.

Future required distributions

Traditional retirement accounts are generally subject to required minimum distribution rules. Roth IRAs do not require distributions while the original owner is alive. The IRS explains current RMD requirements.

A conversion may reduce the balance used to calculate future required distributions. Whether the potential benefit justifies current taxes and Medicare premiums requires an individualized analysis.

The surviving spouse’s tax situation

After one spouse dies, the survivor may eventually file as a single taxpayer while maintaining many of the household’s previous income sources.

The survivor may have a smaller standard deduction, narrower tax brackets, one Social Security benefit, and lower individual IRMAA thresholds. Managing pretax account balances while both spouses are alive may therefore affect the survivor’s future taxes and Medicare premiums.

Future tax flexibility

Roth assets can provide a source of qualified tax free withdrawals. That flexibility may help a retiree manage income during a year involving a major purchase, healthcare expense, investment opportunity, or other unusual cash need.

This does not mean a Roth conversion is automatically beneficial. The current conversion tax, Medicare premiums, state taxes, investment horizon, estate objectives, and future withdrawal needs all matter.

When Limiting a Conversion May Make Sense

Keeping income below an IRMAA threshold may be reasonable when:

  • The conversion provides only a modest projected long term benefit
  • The household is very close to the threshold
  • Both spouses would be affected by the next IRMAA tier
  • Additional income would also affect other deductions, credits, or healthcare costs
  • The tax must be paid from the converted retirement assets
  • The household expects lower tax rates later
  • A move to a lower tax state is planned
  • Cash flow is already tight

The decision should be based on the combined effect, not on IRMAA alone.

Someone who would pay $5,000 in additional taxes and Medicare premiums to create only a small potential benefit may decide to convert less. Someone facing substantial future taxable distributions may reasonably reach a different conclusion.

When Paying IRMAA May Be Worth Considering

Temporarily accepting IRMAA may deserve consideration when:

  • The household is in a relatively favorable tax period
  • A large traditional IRA could create substantial future taxable withdrawals
  • Social Security and pension income will begin later
  • The conversion can be paid from accessible nonretirement funds
  • The surviving spouse could face higher future taxes
  • Roth flexibility is important for future expenses or legacy goals
  • Remaining below the threshold would require giving up a larger multiyear planning opportunity

This is not a recommendation to cross an IRMAA threshold. It is a reminder that minimizing one year’s premium does not necessarily minimize lifetime costs.

Coordinate IRMAA With Social Security and Retirement Income

Many retirees experience several distinct income periods:

  1. Employment income during the final working years
  2. Portfolio withdrawals after retirement
  3. Social Security and pension income
  4. Medicare enrollment
  5. Required distributions from pretax accounts

The years between retirement and the beginning of Social Security or required distributions may create a useful tax planning window. They may also overlap with Affordable Care Act coverage before age 65 or Medicare shortly afterward.

A conversion strategy should therefore consider:

  • When Social Security will begin
  • Which accounts will fund living expenses
  • Whether Marketplace health insurance is being used
  • When each spouse becomes eligible for Medicare
  • Expected capital gains and investment distributions
  • Future required distributions
  • State income taxes
  • Cash available for taxes
  • The potential tax situation of a surviving spouse

Pearl’s Retirement Planning in 2026 guide explains how several of these rules interact.

Can You Appeal an IRMAA Determination?

An IRMAA determination may sometimes be reconsidered following an approved life changing event that reduces income.

Social Security’s current form identifies events such as marriage, divorce, death of a spouse, work stoppage, work reduction, loss of pension income, and certain losses of income producing property. Retirement or a substantial reduction in work may therefore allow someone to request that Social Security use more recent income information. Review Form SSA-44.

A Roth conversion itself is not listed as a life changing event. Someone who retires and then voluntarily completes a large conversion should not assume that the conversion income will be disregarded.

A Better IRMAA Planning Process

Rather than automatically stopping at the first Medicare threshold, compare several conversion amounts.

For each alternative, estimate:

  • Federal income tax
  • State income tax
  • Part B IRMAA
  • Part D IRMAA
  • Future pretax account balances
  • Potential required distributions
  • Social Security taxation
  • The survivor’s projected tax position
  • Available cash for taxes
  • Flexibility created by additional Roth assets

The comparison should extend beyond a single tax year. It should also be updated before year end using actual income instead of relying exclusively on an estimate prepared months earlier.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a Roth conversion count as income for IRMAA?

The taxable portion of a Roth conversion generally increases adjusted gross income and can affect the MAGI used for IRMAA. Nondeductible IRA basis may change how much of a conversion is taxable.

How far back does Medicare look when calculating IRMAA?

Social Security generally uses tax information from two years before the premium year. If that information is unavailable, older available information may sometimes be used.

Is IRMAA permanent?

No. IRMAA is recalculated for each premium year using the applicable income information. A one time income event may cause a temporary increase rather than a permanent surcharge.

Should I stop a Roth conversion at the IRMAA threshold?

Not automatically. The additional premium should be compared with current taxes, potential future required distributions, expected tax rates, and the value of additional Roth flexibility.

Do qualified Roth IRA withdrawals count toward IRMAA?

Qualified Roth IRA distributions generally are not included in adjusted gross income. That can provide additional income flexibility, although Roth contribution, conversion, and distribution rules must be followed.

Can retirement reduce an existing IRMAA surcharge?

Possibly. Work stoppage and work reduction are recognized life changing events. A beneficiary may be able to ask Social Security to use more recent income information by filing Form SSA-44 and providing the required evidence.

What other income can trigger IRMAA?

Income affecting IRMAA may include wages, pension income, taxable retirement withdrawals, taxable Social Security, interest, dividends, capital gains, Roth conversions, and tax exempt interest. The complete tax return should be reviewed.

Bringing Taxes and Medicare Together

IRMAA should be managed, but it should not be feared in isolation.

For people approaching retirement with substantial pretax savings, the goal is to coordinate Medicare premiums with Roth conversions, Social Security, portfolio withdrawals, taxes, healthcare, future required distributions, and the needs of a surviving spouse.

Pearl Wealth Group’s Your Financial EKG™ retirement planning process evaluates how these decisions work together. You can also begin with the Can I Retire? Retirement Readiness Tool.

Disclosure

Pearl Wealth Group, LLC is an investment adviser registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training.

This material is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as personalized investment, tax, legal, Social Security, Medicare, or insurance advice. Tax laws, Medicare premiums, income thresholds, and retirement plan rules may change. Investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. No investment or tax strategy can guarantee a particular outcome. Consult qualified investment, tax, legal, and healthcare professionals regarding your individual circumstances.

Scroll to Top
Call Now Button