Should I Roll Over My 401(k) to an IRA?
When you leave a job or prepare for retirement, you must decide what to do with the money in your former employer’s 401(k). You may be able to leave it where it is, move it into a new employer’s plan, roll it into an IRA, or take a distribution.
Should you roll over your 401(k) to an IRA?
The answer depends on your retirement goals, investment choices, fees, withdrawal needs, tax situation, legal protections, and the services available through each account. An IRA rollover can be helpful, but it is not automatically the best choice for everyone.
Before moving your retirement savings, compare every available option and understand what you may gain or give up.
What Is a 401(k) Rollover?
A 401(k) rollover moves money from an employer sponsored retirement plan into another eligible retirement account.
A rollover may move money into:
- A traditional IRA
- A Roth IRA
- A new employer’s 401(k) or other eligible retirement plan
A direct rollover of pretax money into another pretax retirement account generally does not create current taxable income. The money continues growing tax deferred until it is withdrawn.
Moving pretax 401(k) money into a Roth IRA is different. That transaction is generally treated as a Roth conversion, and the taxable portion is included in your income for the year of the conversion.
The IRS rollover guidance explains which retirement accounts can receive rollovers and how the transfer process works.
What Are Your Options for an Old 401(k)?
Most people leaving an employer have four primary choices.
Leave the Money in Your Former Employer’s Plan
Many plans allow former employees to keep their accounts in the plan.
This option may make sense when the plan offers:
- Low cost investment choices
- Institutional investment pricing
- Useful planning tools or services
- Strong legal protections
- Access to withdrawals under the age 55 exception
Possible disadvantages include limited investment choices, restrictive withdrawal rules, and having retirement savings spread across multiple accounts.
You should review the plan’s summary plan description, investment menu, participant fee disclosure, and distribution rules before deciding.
Move the Money Into a New Employer’s Plan
If your new employer’s plan accepts incoming rollovers, you may be able to move the old account into the new plan.
This can simplify your finances by keeping more of your retirement savings in one place. It may also preserve certain workplace plan features and legal protections.
However, the new plan may have higher fees, fewer investment choices, or less flexibility than your old plan or an IRA. Not every employer plan accepts rollovers.
Roll the 401(k) Into an IRA
An IRA may provide access to a wider range of investments and more flexibility when coordinating investment management, retirement income, beneficiaries, and tax planning.
A rollover IRA may also make it easier to consolidate several former employer plans into one account.
However, an IRA may involve account fees, investment expenses, transaction costs, or an advisory fee. IRA legal protections can also differ from the protections available through an employer plan.
More investment choices do not automatically make an IRA better. The additional choices and services should provide meaningful value for your situation.
Take a Cash Distribution
You can withdraw the money instead of rolling it into another retirement account.
The taxable portion of the distribution is generally included in your income. If you are younger than age 59½, an additional 10 percent tax may also apply unless you qualify for an exception.
Cashing out can also reduce the amount available to support your future retirement. Taxes, possible additional taxes, and the loss of future tax deferred growth should all be considered before taking a distribution.
The SEC’s retirement guidance confirms these four general options.
How Do a 401(k) and an IRA Compare?
The details depend on the specific plan and IRA provider, but the following areas deserve careful review.
| Consideration | Employer 401(k) | IRA |
|---|---|---|
| Investment choices | Selected by the plan | Often offers a broader range |
| Fees | May include plan, administrative, and investment fees | May include account, investment, transaction, and advisory fees |
| Professional guidance | Varies by plan | May include ongoing investment and retirement planning |
| Withdrawals | Controlled by plan rules | Often provides greater distribution flexibility |
| Early withdrawal rules | The age 55 exception may apply in certain situations | The age 55 exception does not apply to IRAs |
| Loans | Some active employer plans permit loans | IRA loans are not permitted |
| Legal protections | Employer plans generally receive broad federal protection | Bankruptcy protection applies, while other protections can vary by state |
| Employer stock | Special tax treatment may be available | Rolling employer stock into an IRA may eliminate that opportunity |
| Required distributions | Special rules may apply if you are still working | Required distribution rules generally apply at the applicable age |
These are general differences. Your plan documents, account agreement, employment status, age, state law, and tax circumstances determine which rules apply.
Compare the Total Costs
Do not compare accounts using only one expense number.
A 401(k) may have:
- Plan administration fees
- Recordkeeping fees
- Investment fund expenses
- Service fees
- Distribution or transaction charges
An IRA may have:
- Custodial or account fees
- Investment fund expenses
- Trading costs
- Advisory or management fees
- Fees associated with particular investments or services
Some employer plans offer access to low cost institutional investments. Other plans may be relatively expensive. An IRA can be less expensive or more expensive depending on the provider, investments, and services selected.
The Department of Labor’s 401(k) fee guide explains the different expenses that may exist inside a workplace retirement plan.
Consider the Services You Will Receive
Cost is important, but it should not be considered by itself.
An IRA may provide services such as:
- Ongoing investment management
- Retirement income planning
- Tax aware withdrawal planning
- Beneficiary coordination
- Roth conversion planning
- Required distribution planning
- Regular retirement plan reviews
An employer plan may provide low cost investments, educational materials, planning tools, telephone assistance, or access to professional guidance.
The question is whether the services you receive provide enough value to justify their cost.
The SEC’s guidance for retirement account recommendations identifies costs, services, investment choices, withdrawal rules, creditor protections, required distributions, and employer stock as important rollover considerations.
Understand the Age 55 Exception
If you separate from your employer during or after the calendar year in which you reach age 55, withdrawals from that employer’s qualified retirement plan may qualify for an exception to the 10 percent additional tax.
This exception generally does not transfer to an IRA.
For example, someone retiring at age 57 may want to use part of a 401(k) for retirement income before reaching age 59½. Rolling the entire account into an IRA could eliminate access to the age 55 exception.
The exception applies to the plan connected to the qualifying separation from service. It does not automatically apply to every retirement account you own.
The rules and additional exceptions are explained in IRS Publication 575.
Review Any Employer Stock Before a Rollover
If your 401(k) contains highly appreciated employer stock, investigate net unrealized appreciation before completing a rollover.
Under certain conditions, employer stock distributed from a qualified plan may receive special tax treatment. Rolling the stock directly into an IRA may eliminate that opportunity.
Net unrealized appreciation is complicated and is not appropriate in every situation. Tax treatment must be weighed against investment risk, including the risk of holding too much money in one company’s stock.
Consult a qualified tax professional before moving employer stock from a retirement plan.
Check for an Outstanding 401(k) Loan
Leaving an employer with an outstanding plan loan can create tax complications.
Depending on the plan, the unpaid balance may become a plan loan offset. If the amount is not handled correctly, it may become taxable and could be subject to an additional tax.
Review the loan terms and rollover deadlines with the plan administrator and a qualified tax professional before initiating a rollover.
Take Any Required Distribution First
A required minimum distribution cannot be rolled into another retirement account.
If you are subject to a required distribution for the year, you generally must take that amount before rolling the remaining eligible balance into an IRA or another employer plan.
Current rules for workplace plans and IRAs are available through the IRS required minimum distribution guidance.
Use a Direct Rollover When Appropriate
A direct rollover sends the money from the 401(k) directly to the receiving IRA or retirement plan. The check may also be made payable to the receiving institution for your benefit.
For a qualifying direct rollover, federal income tax generally is not withheld.
If the distribution is paid directly to you, the employer plan generally must withhold 20 percent of the taxable amount. You normally have 60 days to deposit the distribution into an eligible retirement account.
To roll over the entire balance, you may need to replace the withheld amount using money from another source. Any portion that is not rolled over may become taxable and could be subject to an additional tax.
A direct rollover can help avoid withholding and reduce the risk of missing the 60 day deadline.
Can You Roll a 401(k) Into a Roth IRA?
You may be able to move pretax 401(k) money into a Roth IRA, but the taxable portion is generally treated as income in the year of the conversion.
A Roth conversion can affect:
- Your federal and state income taxes
- Medicare income related premiums
- The taxation of Social Security benefits
- Health insurance subsidies
- Other deductions and tax credits
A conversion should be evaluated as part of a multiyear retirement tax strategy. Read our guide, Should I Convert My 401(k) to a Roth IRA?, before combining a rollover with a Roth conversion.
When Might Leaving the Money in the 401(k) Make Sense?
Keeping money in the former employer’s plan may deserve consideration when:
- The plan has low fees
- You are satisfied with the investment choices
- You may need the age 55 withdrawal exception
- The plan offers valuable services or stable value options
- You want to retain the plan’s legal protections
- You hold appreciated employer stock
- Moving the account would create unnecessary costs
Leaving the account where it is does not have to be permanent. You may be able to revisit the decision later.
When Might an IRA Rollover Make Sense?
An IRA rollover may deserve consideration when:
- You want to consolidate several retirement accounts
- The current plan has limited or expensive investment choices
- You want ongoing investment management
- You need more flexible retirement income planning
- You want to coordinate withdrawals with Social Security and taxes
- You are considering a series of Roth conversions
- The IRA’s services and features justify its total cost
The decision should be based on your actual plan and the specific IRA being considered.
A Hypothetical Example
Consider someone who retires at age 57 and expects to use part of a former employer’s 401(k) before reaching age 59½.
The employer plan has reasonable fees and permits distributions after separation from service. Because the age 55 exception may apply, immediately rolling the entire account into an IRA could reduce access to the money without an additional tax.
Depending on the plan’s rules, the person might leave some or all of the money in the 401(k) until age 59½. A partial rollover might also be considered if the plan permits it.
Now consider someone retiring at age 65 with several old employer plans, no outstanding loans, and no appreciated employer stock. That person wants ongoing investment management, coordinated withdrawals, and annual Roth conversion planning.
Consolidating the accounts into an IRA could make the retirement plan easier to manage if the expected services and flexibility justify the fees.
These examples are for illustration only. They are not recommendations.
How Pearl Wealth Group Evaluates a 401(k) Rollover
Pearl Wealth Group evaluates an old 401(k) as part of your overall retirement plan rather than treating the rollover as an isolated transaction.
Through Your Financial EKG™, we review:
- Your available rollover and distribution options
- The investments and fees inside your current plan
- The investments, services, and costs available through an IRA
- Your retirement income needs
- Your tax situation
- Your age and expected retirement date
- The age 55 exception
- Employer stock and outstanding plan loans
- Required distributions
- Roth conversion opportunities
- How the decision coordinates with Social Security and other income
The goal is to help you understand the advantages, disadvantages, costs, and tax considerations associated with each available option.
If Pearl Wealth Group recommends moving assets into an account it manages, Pearl may receive advisory compensation from that account. This financial incentive should be considered when comparing the rollover with leaving assets in the employer plan or moving them to another plan. Please review Pearl Wealth Group’s Form CRS and Form ADV for information about services, fees, and conflicts of interest.
Frequently Asked Questions About 401(k) Rollovers
Do I have to roll over my 401(k) when I leave my job?
No. Your plan may allow you to leave the account where it is. You may also be able to move it into a new employer’s plan, roll it into an IRA, take a distribution, or use a combination of options.
Is a direct 401(k) rollover taxable?
A direct rollover of pretax money into another pretax eligible retirement account generally does not create current taxable income. Moving pretax money into a Roth IRA is generally taxable as a Roth conversion.
How long do I have to complete a 401(k) rollover?
A direct rollover is transferred directly to the receiving account and generally avoids the standard 60 day deadline. If the distribution is paid to you, you normally have 60 days to complete the rollover.
Can I roll over only part of my 401(k)?
Some plans permit partial rollovers, while others place restrictions on partial distributions. Ask the plan administrator about the specific rules before making a decision.
Is an IRA always better than a 401(k)?
No. An IRA may offer more investment choices and planning flexibility, but a 401(k) may offer lower costs, useful investments, strong legal protections, or withdrawal provisions that are not available through an IRA.
Can I withdraw money after completing a rollover?
Yes, but income taxes and an additional tax may apply. Rolling money from a 401(k) into an IRA may also affect whether the age 55 exception remains available.
Can I roll a Roth 401(k) into a Roth IRA?
A designated Roth 401(k) balance can generally be rolled into a Roth IRA. The rules governing qualified distributions and holding periods should be reviewed before making the transfer.
Can Pearl Wealth Group help me evaluate an old 401(k)?
Yes. Pearl Wealth Group can help you compare your available options and understand how the decision may affect your investments, taxes, retirement income, Roth conversion strategy, and overall retirement plan.
Get Help Evaluating Your Old 401(k)
A 401(k) rollover can affect much more than where your investments are held. It can influence your fees, taxes, withdrawal choices, legal protections, and retirement income strategy.
Before moving the account, make sure you understand both what you may gain and what you may give up.
Pearl Wealth Group is based in Michigan and works virtually with clients throughout the United States where properly registered or exempt from registration.
[Schedule a Retirement Planning Conversation]
Important Disclosure
This information is provided for educational purposes only and should not be interpreted as personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. The appropriate decision depends on your individual circumstances and the rules of your retirement plan.
Pearl Wealth Group, LLC is an investment adviser registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration does not imply a particular level of skill or training. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal.
Consult your retirement plan administrator and qualified investment, tax, and legal professionals before completing a rollover or distribution.